LMLucas Moreau
Back to the blog

Published on September 23, 2026

AI and work: dignity beyond productivity

A task that once took two hours now takes twenty minutes. At first, it seems simply an improvement. Then comes a new expectation: if we are faster, we can do much more. The time saved disappears and the measure of work shifts again.

A Christian perspective on AI at work asks us to consider the result, the people involved and how benefits are distributed together. Productivity provides information; by itself, it does not describe the quality of a workplace.

The question raised by Magnifica Humanitas

In Magnifica Humanitas, no. 112, Leo XIV warns against reducing the person to a project to be optimised.

We can use this reference to begin a concrete assessment. Our suggested criterion is to observe what happens to work before and after a tool is introduced: how many tasks are completed, but also which responsibilities and skills remain visible.

A case: an assistant drafting customer replies

Imagine a small organisation adopting an assistant to write emails. This is a hypothetical case. The program suggests texts; a person rereads and sends them.

A superficial assessment would measure the number of replies. A more useful one would include at least four elements: accuracy, review time, handling of exceptions and the sender’s understanding of the case.

A quick reply may contain a promise the organisation cannot keep. A polite formula may overlook a particular difficulty. An accurate message, on the other hand, may free up attention for cases that require listening.

The difference becomes apparent when actual work is examined with the people doing it.

Four questions to bring to a meeting

Which difficulty do we want to reduce? Describing a precise problem prevents the adoption of a system merely because it is available. Copying data, finding documents and assessing a situation are different activities.

Who can recognise an incorrect result? If nobody has the time or expertise to check, formally appointing a reviewer achieves little. We need to understand what they can correct and when they can stop the process.

Who is still learning the profession? A junior colleague may need to practise exactly the tasks that seem easy to automate. Rotation, mentoring or time working without assistance may be needed.

Who benefits from the time saved? It may become training, customer care, reduced pressure or simply a heavier workload. Making the choice explicit allows discussion.

These questions concern businesses, associations and Church organisations. In each setting, the answers need to fit the activities and people involved.

A thirty-day trial

Before changing a process, describe how it works today. Choose a limited activity and record the time it takes, the errors found and the situations requiring particular attention.

During the trial, ask workers to report difficulties that do not appear in the counts: repeated checks, results that are hard to explain and lost opportunities for discussion. At the end, place this information alongside the speed measurements.

A simple table can have five columns: activity, observed benefit, problem encountered, responsible person and proposed correction. The outcome might be to continue, modify the use or suspend it. A reasoned suspension also produces useful knowledge.

When anxiety concerns our own worth

Not every question can be resolved through a procedure. Knowing that a tool performs part of our work may touch our identity, security and relationships with others.

Here, we need to acknowledge the difficulty without making it a personal failing. Learning is an important responsibility; feeling that we must continually prove we deserve a place in the human community is a different burden.

Faith makes room to discuss change while keeping the whole person in view. The conversation can continue with soul, conscience and capabilities and the everyday guide to Magnifica Humanitas.

To connect the ethics of work with Christian anthropology, discover Lucas Moreau’s essay. If it is the reading you are looking for, the website also provides a link to purchase it on Amazon.