We want to recover from illness, remember better and live longer. It is understandable that promises of overcoming limits attract attention. When the discussion turns to the definitive disappearance of vulnerability or the preservation of a person on a digital medium, however, the questions change.
A comparison between transhumanism and Christian faith requires us to distinguish a concrete technical benefit from a promise about the person’s ultimate destiny. Accepting treatment, assessing enhancement and believing in technological salvation are positions that need separate discussion.
The reference in Magnifica Humanitas
In Magnifica Humanitas, nos. 115–118, Leo XIV examines transhumanism, human dignity and the meaning of limits.
To explore the issue without confusing different levels, we suggest three reading questions: what problem is being addressed? What benefit has been demonstrated? What idea of the person supports the promise? The answers may carry different degrees of certainty.
Care: identifying suffering and a benefit
Imagine a tool that helps someone communicate. The first assessment concerns how it works, its benefits, risks and conditions of access. Then we need to listen to the person using it: what does it make possible in their life?
Describing assistance in this way keeps the person and context visible. It avoids turning every application into an announcement about transcending humanity.
Language also deserves attention. A person using technical support does not become an incomplete human being awaiting correction. An aid can meet a need without defining the worth of the person benefiting from it.
Enhancement: asking who sets the standard
An intervention intended to improve performance raises further questions. Who wants that improvement? How freely? What happens to those who cannot or do not wish to obtain it?
Consider an imaginary workplace where an enhanced capability gradually becomes a requirement. A choice presented as an individual opportunity might become pressure on everyone. Assessing it requires attention to the social environment as well as individual preference.
This does not justify one judgement covering very different technologies. It does offer a criterion: describe benefits alongside the expectations they may generate and the people at risk of exclusion. The issue also emerges in the use of AI at work.
Promising immortality: clarifying what would be preserved
A voice recording, a collection of memories and a simulation of someone’s speech can preserve traces of a life. It does not follow that the person continues living in that system.
When we encounter promises of “digital immortality,” we should therefore ask exactly what the expression means. An archive? A simulated conversational partner? A philosophical hypothesis about personal continuity? These answers need to remain distinguishable.
From the perspective of the Catechism, nos. 362–366, the unity of body and soul rules out treating the person as a simple set of transferable data. This theological position should be stated as such and discussed precisely.
A limit does not automatically become a good
Recognising finitude does not authorise us to minimise another person’s suffering. It would be easy to tell someone to “accept their limits” while doing nothing to help.
A more demanding question is: what can I alleviate, and what presence can I offer? We can work for a more liveable life without requiring every vulnerability to disappear before that life deserves welcome.
This criterion also concerns the way we speak about ourselves. Needing help is not a personal defeat; it may call for shared responsibility, appropriate tools and more attentive relationships.
How to read a technological promise
Choose an announcement and underline separately the verifiable results, predictions and claims about life’s meaning. Check what evidence is offered for each step.
If the demonstration of a limited capability is used to promise a solution to death, pain or loneliness, that leap needs to be recognised and argued. We can remain interested in research while keeping this critical question open.
To develop the discussion between progress and Christian anthropology, discover Christian Faith in the Age of Artificial Intelligence. The presentation of Lucas Moreau’s essay helps you decide whether it is the right reading for your questions.